Following the Decision Behind a Marketing Motion

Tracing the inputs, conditions, and judgment that shape applied marketing decisions.

I’ve been thinking a lot about what happens in the space between a business identifying a need and marketing determining its response.

The more I look at that space, the more moving pieces seem to be inside it: business context, customer knowledge, previous marketing learning, expectations, capabilities, operating conditions, interpretation, judgment. I’ve spent a couple articles exploring those concepts abstractly, but there’s a point where continuing to talk about the space in general makes it harder for me to see what’s actually happening inside it during application.

So I figured I would try something more tangible.

I’m going to make up a business situation, give marketing some information to work with, and follow the reasoning process as the response becomes more applied.

My goal isn’t to determine the best marketing response to this fictional business problem. I simply need the team to make decisions so I can take a closer look at what those decisions have available to reason from and how they’re shaped. Deal?

The hypothetical situation

Imagine an established B2B services company is introducing a new service alongside its existing offerings.

Customer and prospect conversations have repeatedly surfaced a problem the company believes this new service can address. Ultimately, the business wants the service to become a new source of revenue. But because the offering is new, the business also wants to validate the service as well as sharpen its understanding of who is most likely to buy before it continues this investment.

There’s enough existing knowledge to form an initial hypothesis about the audience. The business believes the problem is most relevant to mid-market companies and tends to involve senior technology and operations leaders. Sales and customer-facing teams have encountered versions of the problem in real conversations, including some existing customers using complementary services.

The expectation of marketing is to help create relevant commercial interest and surface viable opportunities around the new service while producing useful audience engagement insights.

For this scenario, I’m assuming that marketing has meaningful authority to recommend and shape its response. The business is bringing marketing a need, context, and an expectation of contribution, not a predetermined instruction to run a particular motion.

This also isn’t the first time the company has asked marketing to support a new service launch. The marketing team has previous effort and learning to reference, working relationships with sales and customer-facing teams, established systems and channels, and enough capability to form and execute a reasonable response.

So the marketing team decides to start by making the audience more applied. The business has provided a useful hypothesis, but marketing still needs enough specificity to identify who it can actually reach and then make subsequent decisions about channels, messaging, offers, and production.

Let’s start there and see what happens!

Who are we going to try to reach?

Our starting audience is mid-market companies where senior technology and operations leaders are likely to encounter the problem. That gives marketing some direction, but it isn’t yet the same as having an audience it can activate.

If marketing wants to pull relevant contacts from the CRM or define an audience on a paid platform, it needs criteria that can be specifically identified and targeted. And if marketing wants to tailor its approach around what different groups already know about the company and the problem, it needs to understand and identify which relationships exist already.

Sales and customer teams add more context from their customer interactions. They know that some existing customers have encountered it, particularly among companies already using a complementary service. Their conversations also provide more context about the roles involved and the job titles that seem relevant.

At this point, I can already see several inputs informing the audience decision:

Business audience hypothesis + customer and sales knowledge + existing audience data + previous engagement + marketing judgment

To move from the audience concept to an applied audience that can be specifically targeted, marketing considers:

  • Which existing customers match the company and role characteristics and already use the complementary service?
  • Which existing prospects match those characteristics?
  • Which of them have engaged with related services, content, or subject matter before?
  • And how much of the hypothesized audience sits outside the company’s CRM entirely?

Marketing identifies three distinct audience groups from that analysis.

The first is existing customers in the CRM that fit the profile, including a small number of especially strong-fit accounts already using the complementary service. This group fits the audience hypothesis, has existing relationships that can be leveraged, and is readily available within the CRM already.

The second is existing prospects in the CRM that match the company and role characteristics, with some having previously engaged around related services. This is another relevant group with some existing engagement that can be identified in the CRM.

The third is a net-new audience that fits the same broad profile but has no existing relationship with the company. This group allows marketing to test the audience hypothesis outside its existing relationship base while developing access to the segment if it proves relevant.

Of course, choosing these groups doesn’t establish that these are the “right” audiences. But it does equip marketing with an applied audience decision it can work from and test across meaningfully different segments.

Now that marketing knows who it’s trying to reach, it can continue reasoning the marketing response.

How are we going to reach them?

Part of this decision was already embedded within the audience selection. When marketing identified existing customers and prospects in the CRM, it wasn’t only establishing who fit the audience profile. It was also identifying people the company already had a way to reach.

That gives marketing several direct options. The broader customer and prospect groups can be reached through segmented marketing email. And for the small number of high-priority customer accounts, marketing can enable the relationship owner to call and email their point of contact.

The net-new audience is different. Those contacts don’t currently exist within the CRM, so marketing needs to leverage a channel that can reach people matching the relevant company and role criteria.

Marketing has supported previous campaigns with paid acquisition, so the team considers both Google Ads and LinkedIn Ads. The team discovers that there is relevant search volume around the problem, but the keywords are competitive and costly. With a limited budget and a goal of testing a specific audience, marketing doesn’t want to spread its paid investment across both channels. The team decides to start with a focused LinkedIn Ads campaign and leaves Google Ads as an option to revisit after launch.

Marketing also decides to create a dedicated service page on the company website. The targeted efforts above are designed to reach a specified audience, and the website page gives the new service an owned destination that can be discovered by current and future visitors.

What are we going to say and offer?

Marketing may be able to define and reach its desired audience, but it still has to give them a reason to take action.

Marketing knows that it needs to communicate the problem in a way that the audience recognizes, demonstrate why addressing it matters, explain how the new service can help, and give interested leads a reasonable next step.

The team isn’t starting from scratch here. Customer and sales conversations have given the company some understanding of how the problem shows up, the consequences that customers face, and the language they use to describe it. The company also has existing service positioning, related proof, and previous engagement data.

At this point, I can see another combination of inputs informing the response:

Audience decision + customer problem and consequences + sales and customer language + existing positioning + previous engagement + previous launch learning + marketing judgment

So marketing does its best to develop shared positioning around the problem, its consequences, and how the new service can help, all grounded in what’s known about the customer experience. However, the audience distinctions from earlier change how marketing decides to introduce that messaging to each group.

Existing customers already know the company, and some already use a complementary service. Marketing can build from that existing trust and context, positioning the new service as continued support that can address a related need.

Existing prospects haven’t bought yet, but some have previously engaged around related services. Marketing can reconnect the new offering to that earlier interest and treat this outreach as another opportunity to work together.

The net-new audience has none of that context. Marketing can’t rely on an existing relationship or previous engagement to create relevance, so the communication has to do more work upfront to demonstrate that the company understands the problem and why it matters before asking the audience to care about the company or its service.

Getting someone to understand the message still isn’t the same as getting them to raise their hand.

Last time the company launched a service, marketing created a substantial buyer guide to support it. This time, the company has a less validated understanding of how this audience thinks about the particular need.

Rather than investing heavily in an educational asset built around assumptions the team hasn’t tested yet, marketing decides to start with a consultation as the primary offer. The consultation gives interested prospects a relatively direct way to discuss their current situation, explore their options for addressing it, and determine whether a deeper sales conversation makes sense.

If the initial response surfaces recurring questions, objections, or information needs, marketing can use that learning to decide whether a deeper resource is warranted and what it would need to address.

Two distinctions feel important to me:

Previous experience didn’t necessarily tell the team what to do, but it gave the team something real to reason from.

And uncertainty didn’t stop the team from acting. It affected how much the team chose to invest before learning more.

What actually needs to be produced?

To me, this is the point when the response becomes more recognizable as marketing work.

We started with an abstract business need to validate and grow a new service. Now marketing can identify the needed assets and deliverables:

  • A dedicated website service page
  • Segmented launch and follow-up customer and prospect emails
  • Email templates for relationship owners handling the highest-priority accounts
  • LinkedIn Ads creative

And because learning about the audience and service is part of the business objective, the team also needs enough tracking and downstream visibility to understand what happens when the work goes into the world.

Each of those deliverables carries its own layer of decisions.

The service page needs structure, copy, design, and calls to action.

The emails need subject lines, body copy, target lists, exclusion lists, senders, and asset links.

The relationship owners need enough context and messaging support to personalize their customer outreach without simply copying a mass-marketing email into a one-to-one conversation.

The ads need targeting, exclusions, budget, copy, creative, and destinations.

The measurement setup needs to distinguish enough of these audiences and paths for marketing to understand what generated engagement, what was passed to sales, and what happened afterward.

These can look like much smaller decisions than deciding which audience to pursue or which channels to use, but they aren’t necessarily disconnected from the business need because they’re happening at a deeper level of execution.

Take an email subject line.

By the time someone is writing it, they’re several decisions removed from the original business need. But the subject line can still inherit decisions already made about the audience, the problem, the message, the offer, the desired action, and the channel being used.

Some of that reasoning has already traveled downstream through the decisions that shaped the work, so the person writing the email doesn’t necessarily need to reconstruct the entire business case for the new service every time they make a production decision.

That makes me look a little differently at the visible marketing activity itself.


The email, ad, webpage, or outreach template may be the tangible deliverable that we can see, but it’s the applied end of a much longer chain of context, judgment, and decisions we don’t always see.

What does this response allow us to learn?

Just as previous marketing experience helped inform decisions about this marketing response, the team recognizes that learnings from this experience can shape future considerations and decisions.

Marketing will observe which audience segments engage, whether the hypothesized problem framing attracts attention, how known audiences respond compared with the net-new group, what people do after reaching the service page, and whether LinkedIn provides useful access to the desired audience.

But marketing engagement is only part of the picture.

The company also learns from what happens downstream.

  • Who moves to a sales conversation?
  • What recurring questions or objections appear?
  • Does the problem sound the same when a prospective buyer describes it in a live conversation?
  • Which companies and roles become viable opportunities?
  • Who eventually buys?

Those answers could affect much more than a campaign performance report.

They could sharpen the audience definition. Change the message. Make another channel worth testing. Give the team a reason to create the buyer resource it deliberately postponed. Surface a need for different sales support. Reveal another segment worth investigating. Or give the business new information about whether and how it wants to continue developing the service.

The previous marketing work gave this team something to reason from when it formed the current response, so today’s execution can become an input into the next response.

What did making this concrete make visible?

We started with a business need and some supporting context.

Then by the end of the exercise, our marketing team had arrived at a service page, segmented emails, paid media, relationship-led outreach supported by marketing, sales and customer-facing support, tracking, and several ways to expand the business’ understanding of the audience.

Sure, we arrived there because I made all of those decisions. But what really interests me is what inputs the team had available to work with and how those inputs shaped the resulting marketing response.

The service launch didn’t move directly from “we think there’s an opportunity here” to an email, webpage, or ad.

In this example, business context, customer knowledge, audience data, previous engagement, previous marketing experience, channel knowledge, existing relationships, operating conditions, and judgment all entered the response at different points during its formation.

I noticed that several inputs contributed to individual decisions. Some inputs remained relevant across multiple decisions. Decisions the team made along the way became inputs for other decisions. By the time we reached the visible production work, some reasoning behind it had already happened upstream.

And the presence of inputs alone wasn’t enough to formulate an applied marketing response. The team still had to evaluate what those inputs meant together and make judgment calls about how to respond.

That’s really what I was hoping to expose by making this exercise more tangible. The space between a business need and an applied marketing response looks simple when I leave it abstract, but following one response all the way through made more of the inputs, relationships, and decisions inside that space more visible.

That leaves me with a question I don’t think this hypothetical answers:

Is the ability to surface, evaluate, and synthesize those inputs into an applied marketing response a capability in and of itself?

That’s where I’m going to continue this exploration.

Portrait of Jacob Olle smiling in a blue shirt

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jacob Olle

Drawing on nearly a decade of marketing experience, Jacob explores the relationship between marketing ideas and business realities. He’s particularly interested in making marketing complexities more accessible, connecting concepts with practical application, and supporting informed, intentional marketing decisions.

More about the author

Discussion

What do you think?

Leave a Reply